Skip Navigation

What Is a Plan of Arrangement? Canada’s Go-To Tool for M&A and Restructuring

If you follow Canadian public company deals, you have probably seen the phrase “plan of arrangement” in almost every friendly takeover announcement. The same court-supervised process is also used to restructure debt without a formal insolvency filing. Here is what a plan of arrangement is, why it has become so popular and why it gives Canadian companies an advantage their U.S. counterparts don’t have.

Most friendly acquisitions of Canadian public companies today are completed the same way. Not through a take-over bid, but through a plan of arrangement.

The same tool is also used for something completely different: helping companies under financial pressure restructure their debt without filing for creditor protection.

Two very different jobs. One process. What ties them together is a simple combination: a securityholder vote, a court’s review of fairness and the power to bind everyone once both are obtained.

What Is a Plan of Arrangement?

A plan of arrangement is a court-supervised process for making fundamental changes to a corporation. It is found in Canada’s corporate statutes, including section 192 of the Canada Business Corporations Act (“CBCA”), section 182 of the Ontario Business Corporations Act and the BC Business Corporations Act.

The process typically follows five steps:

  1. Interim order: the company asks the court to set the rules for the meeting, who votes and the approval threshold
  2. Information circular: securityholders receive a document explaining the plan and how it affects them
  3. Vote: each affected class votes, usually requiring 66⅔% of the votes cast
  4. Final order: the court holds a fairness hearing and approves the plan if it is “fair and reasonable”
  5. Implementation: every step in the plan takes effect on a single date

 

That fourth step is what makes an arrangement different. A judge has to be satisfied the transaction is fair before it happens. And in practice, one of the most important pieces of evidence put in front of that judge is an independent fairness opinion.

“A plan of arrangement isn’t just approved by the people it affects. It is also reviewed by a commercial court judge before it takes effect.”

How Are Plans of Arrangement Used in M&A?

In M&A, an arrangement is the standard way to acquire a Canadian public company on a negotiated basis.

The buyer and the target sign an arrangement agreement. The target’s shareholders vote. The court confirms the deal is fair and reasonable. The buyer ends up owning 100% of the shares.

A few protections are built in:

  1. Dissent rights: shareholders who oppose the deal can ask the court to set a fair value for their shares
  2. Minority protection: if insiders are involved, securities rules (MI 61-101) may require a “majority of the minority” vote and a formal valuation
  3. Board process: the court looks closely at how the board reached its recommendation, including its special committee and its fairness opinion

Why Have Arrangements Become the Preferred M&A Structure?

Because they solve several problems at once.

100% ownership in one step. Once the vote passes and the court approves, every shareholder is bound. Conversely, a take-over bid needs 90% of the shares tendered to squeeze out the rest, or a second-step transaction.

A lower threshold. Two-thirds of the votes cast (66⅔%) is far easier to reach than 90% of all outstanding shares.

Flexibility. One plan can combine multiple elements in one transaction, including: amalgamations, spin-outs, share exchanges, tax planning steps and the treatment of options and warrants.

Access to U.S. investors. Court approval allows a buyer to issue shares to U.S. shareholders under the Section 3(a)(10) exemption, without registering them with the SEC.

Certainty. A court’s fairness finding makes the deal very difficult to challenge after closing.

The take-over bid rules also pushed deals in this direction. Since 2016, take-over bids must stay open for at least 105 days and need a minimum 50% share tender. As take-over bids became slower, arrangements became even more attractive.

As a result, these days take-over bids are mostly used for hostile or unsolicited offers.

Why Does the Fairness Opinion Matter So Much?

No statute requires a fairness opinion for a plan of arrangement. But almost every public M&A arrangement includes one. The reason is the court.

In 2016, the Yukon Court of Appeal overturned the approval of ExxonMobil’s acquisition of InterOil. A key problem was the fairness opinion: it gave a conclusion without including the analysis behind it, and most of the adviser’s fee for the fairness opinion was payable only if the deal closed.

InterOil had to obtain a new independent fairness opinion, on a fixed fee basis with the analysis disclosed, and seek court approval again.

“After InterOil, a fairness opinion that simply says ‘it’s fair’ without showing the work isn’t just weak. It is a risk to the deal itself.”

Canadian securities regulators followed with guidance (Multilateral Staff Notice 61-302) on how fairness opinions should be disclosed, including how the adviser is paid and what relationships it has with the parties.

The practical lesson: an independent fairness opinion, from an adviser paid a fixed fee rather than a success fee, is now typically an important part of any plan of arrangement.

How Are Plans of Arrangement Used in Restructuring?

The second use has nothing to do with selling a company. Here, an arrangement lets a company that is under financial pressure, but not yet insolvent, exchange or amend its debt.

Noteholders vote as a class. The court approves the plan. And the business keeps operating normally.

Key features include:

  1. Who votes: the affected creditors, usually bondholders or noteholders
  2. Solvency: the CBCA requires that the applicant not be insolvent, so a solvent affiliate is often added to the application, an approach the courts have accepted
  3. Who is left out: trade creditors, suppliers and employees are typically untouched
  4. U.S. reach: the plan can be recognized in the U.S. under Chapter 15 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code

 

As in M&A, an independent fairness opinion is commonly provided to show the court that affected creditors and shareholders are being treated fairly compared with the alternatives, such as a CCAA filing or an outright liquidation.

Why Use an Arrangement Instead of the CCAA?

It binds holdouts. A two-thirds vote of the noteholder class binds every holder in that class. Without it, a small group of holders can block a voluntary exchange.

It is faster and cheaper. A CBCA restructuring can often be completed in a few months, without a court-appointed monitor.

It avoids the stigma. Customers, suppliers and employees deal with a business that is operating normally, not one in creditor protection.

Management stays in control. The board and management continue to run the company.

Companies began using arrangements this way during the 2008-2009 financial crisis, and the approach became an established alternative to the CCAA through the 2010s, particularly in the media and energy sectors. Postmedia’s 2016 recapitalization and Concordia International’s 2018 restructuring are two well-known examples.

The limitation is that it only works when the problem is the balance sheet, not the business. A company with operational distress, or one that needs protection from all of its creditors, will still need the CCAA.

“A CBCA arrangement is often the first option considered when a company’s problem is its debt rather than its operations.”

Why Is This a Distinctly Canadian Advantage?

The United States has no single process that does the same thing.

In M&A, U.S. public company deals are done as statutory mergers under state law, usually Delaware, or as a tender offer followed by a short-form merger. There is no court approval step. Fairness is tested after the fact, through shareholder litigation that can drag on long after closing.

In restructuring in the U.S., Section 316(b) of the Trust Indenture Act generally prevents changing a bondholder’s right to payment without that holder’s consent. A small group of holdouts can block an out-of-court deal. The practical alternative is Chapter 11, which is a formal bankruptcy, even when it is filed as a “prepackaged” case.

A Canadian company, by contrast, can bind its shareholders or noteholders with a two-thirds (66%) vote, have a court confirm fairness up front, usually supported by an independent fairness opinion, and extend the result to U.S. holders through Section 3(a)(10) or Chapter 15.

Other Commonwealth countries, including the UK and Australia, use a similar “scheme of arrangement.” But in North America, it is a Canadian advantage, and for companies with U.S. shareholders or U.S.-governed debt it can be the deciding factor in how a transaction is structured.

The Bottom Line

The plan of arrangement has become one of the most useful tools in Canadian corporate law.

For buyers and sellers of public companies, it is the cleanest route to 100% ownership. For companies carrying too much debt, it is a faster, quieter alternative to creditor protection.

In both cases, the court’s review is what gives the result its certainty, and an independent fairness opinion is typically central to that review.

Plan early. Get the process right. And make sure the people telling the court the deal is fair have no stake in whether it closes.

“The power of a plan of arrangement comes from the court’s approval. The strength of that approval depends on the quality of the process behind it.”

Frequently Asked Questions

The opportunities that find you are only one part of the market. Some of the best acquisitions we have sourced for clients were not for sale until we approached them.

There’s a reason why certain companies are approaching you, and others are not. We often compare it to hiring. Some great candidates are actively looking, but many of the best people are happily employed and only move when the right opportunity finds them. Acquisitions work the same way. In our experience, many strong, well-run companies have never considered selling until we reach out with a compelling reason to.

That’s why we help our clients build a larger, proactive funnel. It lets you pursue the companies that best fit your strategy, rather than choosing only from what happens to be available. It also gives you more leverage in negotiations, a better chance of closing deals without a crowded auction, and a wide field of opportunities to compare side by side.

When that happens, the gems really stand out, as do the dogs.

At HDL, we work as your dedicated diamond miners.

Yes. In fact, some of the best acquisition opportunities we have sourced were companies that were not actively for sale when we first approached them.

Absolutely. Approaching “off-market” companies is one of the most valuable things we do. Many owners of strong, well-run businesses have never put their company on the market, but that doesn’t mean they wouldn’t consider the right conversation with the right buyer.

We start by identifying companies that fit your strategy, then reach out directly to the owner. Our approach is respectful and low-pressure. We aren’t asking them to sell. We’re opening a conversation about their plans and whether a partnership could make sense. Owners take the call for many reasons: succession planning, a desire to grow faster with more resources, a wish to take some chips off the table, or simply curiosity about what their business is worth.

We typically keep our buy side client’s identity confidential in these early conversations and only introduce you once the owner has shown genuine interest.

Because these companies aren’t being shopped to other buyers, you often have the chance to build a relationship with the owner, avoid a competitive auction, and negotiate on more favourable terms.

An external M&A Advisor gives you anonymity, transaction experience, additional market reach and a dedicated team that can keep the acquisition program moving without distracting your internal people.

The first reason is that many companies view calls from competitors as nothing short of corporate espionage, someone just fishing for their private information, who may steal their clients or employees.

Even if they do respond, they typically end up sharing far more sensitive and valuable information with your M&A Advisor than they would with your team.

Secondly, your team already has limited bandwidth to run the business. A proper acquisition program takes sustained effort over many months or more, and internal resources often get pulled back into their day jobs, which stalls outreach and follow-up.

Lastly, when engaging an experienced M&A Advisor, you get an entire team working on your project, with a wide range of toolkits, frames of reference, spheres of contacts and unique “tricks of the trade.” Beyond their own outreach, M&A Advisors have long-standing relationships with hundreds of other M&A advisors, lawyers and accountants who provide leads from their own networks.

That said, if you already have an internal team in place, we’re always happy to collaborate and build an even stronger team, all rowing in the same direction.

Finding companies is only the beginning. The real value comes from determining which ones actually fit the acquisition strategy and are worth your management team’s time.

Building a large funnel is important, but your management team’s time is limited, so our job is to make sure the opportunities that reach you are worth it. Before any target moves forward, we work with you to define what a good acquisition looks like for your business, and then we assess each company against those criteria.

We typically look at strategic fit first: whether the company’s products, services, capabilities and customer base complement yours. From there, we consider size and financial profile, including revenue and EBITDA, along with geography, the strength of the management team and how dependent the business is on its owner. Just as important is the human side: the owner’s goals, their likely valuation expectations and how realistic it is that they would transact.

We’re also quick to flag the warning signs that a company isn’t worth pursuing, such as heavy customer concentration, an owner with unrealistic price expectations, declining revenue, or a business that couldn’t operate without its founder.

The result is a focused list of targets that genuinely fit your strategy, so your team spends its time on the gems rather than the dogs.

Expect a few weeks at the front end to align on the acquisition strategy. Once a qualified target is engaged, we typically see a closing process ranging from approximately 90–180 days.

There is typically a “getting to know each other” phase at the front end of our engagements, which is critical to ensuring our efforts are 100% aligned with your goals and growth objectives.

We get to know what you like, and what you don’t like, and cater our market approach accordingly. During this few-week period we analyze your financials and operations, and usually provide some good insights along the way that shape the acquisition strategy.

Once we are up and running, we typically uncover fresh targets right out of the chute, but we prefer to do some preliminary qualification and due diligence before arranging any calls or meetings. This keeps your team from getting bogged down on Zoom calls.

We focus on quality, not quantity.

Once a qualified target comes up, we typically see a closing process ranging anywhere from 90–180 days on average.

You will know who has been approached, who has responded and where conversations stand. We provide detailed progress reporting, typically weekly or bi-weekly.

We have invested in and implemented an advanced cloud-based CRM system with which we track all of our outreach to and interactions with targets on your behalf.

We generate regular, highly detailed reports on our activities and progress, typically weekly or bi-weekly.

Yes. HDL has sourced acquisitions from Canada to China and everywhere in between, supported by an international network of M&A Advisors and transaction professionals.

We have sourced acquisitions from Canada to China and everywhere in between.

If you need to shore up your business in another market, we are primed and ready to hunt for you anywhere.

We have partnerships with M&A Advisors on every continent who can augment our search and offer clients for sale in their direct networks.

HDL’s role does not stop when a target says yes. We stay involved through valuation, structure, negotiation, diligence, financing and closing.

HDL is very involved. Getting a target to the table is a big milestone, but it’s also the point where many deals start falling off the rails. We act as the glue that holds the process together through closing.

Once a serious target is engaged, we help you determine what the business is really worth and how to structure an offer that works for both sides, whether that includes cash at close, an earnout, vendor financing and/or the owner rolling over some equity. We then help prepare the letter of intent and work through purchase-price and structure discussions.

Your management team stays in the driver’s seat on the decisions that matter most: whether the business is the right fit, how it will be integrated and final approval of the terms. We keep everything else moving.

We have extensive experience bringing in lawyers, accountants, lenders and other professionals when they’re needed, and just as importantly, at the right time. Bringing advisors in too early or letting them run without direction is one of the most common ways deal costs build up. We keep every party on track, on schedule and honest, which prevents unnecessary delays and saves you money along the way.

When issues come up in diligence or negotiations, we address them quickly and keep the deal moving toward a successful closing.

We can help optimize the capital structure and work with your lenders, equity investors and other financial partners to help get the financing in place when required.

We will analyze and help you optimize your capital structure for the short, medium and long term, and liaise with your bank lenders, equity investors or other backers as needed to help get the financing in place, if applicable.

We have had instances where a client was unable to finance an acquisition with their existing bank, but after HDL did a proper, comprehensive “work-up” and presentation of the acquisition opportunity, the same bank provided full financing, and more.

HDL works on a combination of a monthly Work Fee and a Success Fee paid when a transaction closes, keeping us focused on both building the acquisition pipeline and getting good deals completed.

We work based on a balanced blend of an ongoing monthly Work Fee combined with Success Fees, a percentage of the value of the target purchased, paid on closing of successful transactions.

This keeps us driving to build a deep, well-qualified funnel of acquisitions, and also ensures we remain highly motivated to get deals closed efficiently.

Our clients have remarked that our experience and expertise has kept them out of trouble and helped them avoid costly mistakes, which the HDL team has seen time and time again.

In a nutshell, the extra investment in engaging HDL in the short to medium term should save you a TON in the long run.

Integration planning should start during due diligence, not the day after closing. We work with your functional teams and external advisors so everyone understands what needs to happen before the deal is done.

We can’t do everything, but we can certainly work with your HR, Operations, Finance, Sales and Marketing teams to plan for integration of your acquisitions.

We like to use the due diligence process to touch on all of these key functional areas so that when the closing date arrives, your team is not scrambling.

We surround you, if needed, with equally minded and efficient lawyers, accountants etc. to make sure your support team matches your company’s stage of growth.

WE CAN HELP

Thinking about selling your Canadian company?

You do not need to know whether you are ready to sell before starting the conversation. Give us a call. After a short conversation, we can give you a preliminary view of what your company may be worth, how a transaction could be structured and how attractive the opportunity may be in today’s market.

Read Blog
HR Blog
Templates Library
Loading, Please wait...
The Library cannot be open, please try it again later.
This field is required.
Invalid email format.
Some of the fields are not filled or invalid.